Skip to content
Curtis Banks Curtis Banks
  • About
    • Our People
    • Careers
    • ESG
  • SIPP
  • SSAS
  • Property
    • Property Videos
  • Investments
  • Literature
  • Insights
    • CPD On Demand
    • Adviser Insights
    • Adviser tools
    • Case Studies
    • News
  • Contact
  • Share Price:  260.00 p
  • Investors
  • Contact

Spotlight On...PCLS Recycling

Back to adviser insights

Share this article:

Spotlight On…PCLS Recycling

 

Global Recycling Day falls on 18 March each year, highlighting the important role of recycling in helping to preserve our planet’s resources for the future. You can learn more about the fantastic initiatives at www.globalrecyclingday.com.

However, pensions are one area where recycling isn’t always such a great idea, specifically when it comes to pension commencement lump sums (PCLS, or tax free cash). Clients who recycle PCLS could end up facing heavy tax penalties.

What is PCLS recycling?

PCLS recycling involves using PCLS payments to make additional pension contributions, in order to gain what HMRC terms ‘artificially high’ amounts of tax relief. Where PCLS recycling takes place, all or part of the PCLS may be deemed an unauthorised payment, carrying the associated tax penalties.

When does PCLS recycling occur?

It’s an understatement to say that the PCLS recycling rules are tricky. Some of the actions that might indicate recycling could also occur as part of normal pension planning. The rules try to take this into account, and as a result are rather complex. There are several conditions that all need to be met, and even HMRC’s guidance acknowledges that not many PCLS payments will be caught by the rules. Still, the heavy tax penalties make it worth watching out for clients who may be caught out.

1. A person receives a PCLS payment, and as a result, there is a ‘significant increase’ in their contributions.

If you think this sounds a little vague and difficult to prove, you’re not alone. As a rule of thumb, HMRC says that a ‘significant increase’ would require the additional contributions (whether personal, employer, or third party) to be worth more than 30% of the contributions that ‘might otherwise have been expected’. Determining what might otherwise have been expected is another challenge altogether: it might, for example, involve looking at the person’s contribution history, or other influencing factors such as the conditions of their employer’s pension scheme. If there’s a significant increase that wasn’t related to the PCLS payment, the condition isn’t met.

2. The recycling was planned in advance.

In many cases this is a key condition: the individual must have made a conscious decision, in advance, to take PCLS in order to make additional contributions. If someone only decided to make the larger contributions after already withdrawing the PCLS, the condition isn’t met. It’s worth noting that in the event of a dispute, the onus is on HMRC to prove that pre-planning took place.

3. The amount of PCLS is more than £7,500.

At least, this has been the case since 6 April 2015: before then, it was 1% of the standard lifetime allowance at the time. This condition looks at all PCLS taken in the previous 12 months, so the rules can’t be avoided by taking several smaller amounts of PCLS.

4. The cumulative amount of the additional contributions is more than 30% of the PCLS.

This uses the same definition of additional contributions as before. The ‘cumulative amount’ requirement is a measure to ensure people can’t avoid the recycling rules by spreading their additional contributions over a period of time. The time period considered is the tax year in question, the two preceding tax years, and the two following tax years.
You can read more about PCLS recycling rules here.

Don’t forget, you can read previous editions of the Spotlight On series on our website.

Kind regards,
Jessica List
Pension Technical Manager

Jessica has been with Curtis Banks for nine years. She has worked in the SIPP Support team helping clients and advisers with general queries, and the Product Technical team working on projects delivering legislative changes and delivering staff training. As Pension Technical Manager she focuses on helping advisers with queries, and writing technical content for Curtis Banks and the trade press.

  • Careers
  • Investors
  • Privacy
  • Modern Slavery Statement
  • Legal
  • Accessibility
Curtis Banks Curtis Banks
  • Curtis Banks Twitter
  • Curtis Banks Linkedin
© 2019 Curtis Banks Group. All rights reserved.
This website is aimed at professional advisers and firms rather than consumers. We do not offer advice on - or judge the suitability of – SIPPs or their investments. If you are a consumer interested in a SIPP you should seek the advice of a financial adviser.
Site by Mr B & Friends

Our secure
portal

Your Future SIPP

Log in

Curtis Banks

Log in

Suffolk Life

Log in
  • Please note: When creating a User ID, please do not use your email address as your User ID as this must be limited to 30 characters maximum.

  • Please note: New registrations for portal access for Advisers will take up to 1 working day to process and you will receive confirmation once your account has been activated. Please do not try and log in before your confirmation is received.

  • Advisers and Clients with previous Suffolk Life portal access should now log in to the Your Future SIPP or Suffolk Life portal. If this is the first time you have logged in to Your Future SIPP portal, simply login with your Suffolk Life details and for security reasons you will be prompted to change your password for future access.

  • Clients with no portal access please contact SIPP Support via phone 01473 296 969 or email sippsupportteam@curtisbanks.co.uk to request an account.

  • Curtis Banks users who have Curtis Banks SIPP or SSAS should continue to log in via the Curtis Banks portal. For any questions regarding Curtis Banks portal access please click here to contact the relevant team.
Tell us what you are
looking for?
    How can i help you today?

    How can I help you today?