Staveley case: summary and outcomes

You may have seen the news on Wednesday that the Supreme Court judgment in the Staveley inheritance tax case has been released, bringing the case to a close six years after the First Tier Tribunal ruling.

We’ve highlighted the key points below, or you can click the button below to read a more detailed analysis and the background to the case.

Staveley Case: Detailed analysis and the background

  • Omission to take pension benefits: Mrs Staveley’s decision not to access her pension funds did create an inheritance tax liability – however, this shouldn’t affect recent cases following a rule change in 2011
  • Transferring while in ill-health: Mrs Staveley’s decision to transfer her pension weeks before her death has not created an inheritance tax liability
  • The judgment clarifies when actions can be considered together as a series of transactions to confer benefits
  • The judgment questions whether death benefits can be conferred as part of a pension transfer, as beneficiaries don’t have any benefits or rights while the pension holder is alive
  • The judgment appears to question whether a pension transfer would always be a transfer of value, by rejecting HMRC’s ‘return to zero’ approach.

Keep up to date with our latest news and updates. Curtis Banks Insights.

Kind regards,
Curtis Banks.

Back to Advisor Insights